Khilafah.com

Saturday
Feb 04th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Why has the Muslim world made no Contribution to Science and Technology?

E-mail Print PDF

Islam is a complete way of life revealed for all of mankind, from the time of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم until the Day of Resurrection. It encompasses rules for every sphere of life including spiritual, economic, social, judicial and political. As Islam came from the Creator of the universe, it is a superior system, free from the inconsistencies and disparities, which riddle man-made systems such as Capitalism and Communism.

With this in mind, we may expect the Muslim world, whose population follows Islam as a religion, to be at the forefront of development and science, as they have at their disposal, a flawless system to regulate their affairs and drive them forward. However, what we find instead is that most of the Muslim world labours in poverty. It is no wonder then that the Muslim world has stagnated when it comes to scientific and technological research. Some of these countries do not even have basic infrastructure in place such as schools, hospitals and roads, which would enable them to have a standard of living considered necessary.

In stark contrast, countries which have adopted the Capitalist economic system, appear to have a monopoly on scientific advancement and are at the forefront of the development of new technologies. The populations of these nations, on the whole have a high standard of living, with their basic needs catered for. This situation begs some very pertinent questions:

- Why do the countries which follow the Capitalist ideology, appear to have advanced if they are following an incorrect doctrine?
- Why has the Muslim world failed to make a contribution to science and development for the last 300 years?
- Is it due to some inherent problem with the deen of Islam or with the Ummah? And what is the way forward for the Ummah?
- Should the Ummah adopt the same system as the Western nations in order to reach the same level of advancement?

Understanding Western development

The countries of Europe and North America have achieved some phenomenal developments in the last few centuries. After the decline of the Roman Empire in the 5th Century CE, Europe broke off into small feudal states, entering a period known as the "Dark Ages" which was marked by cultural and intellectual decline, superstition, an antipathy toward science.

It was during this time that the Muslims conquered Spain and established the Islamic state there. The ruling system of Europe in the Middle Ages consisted of kingdoms, such as England, which were supported by the Roman Catholic Church, and independent city states, such as Venice.

During the Crusades, the knowledge gained in fields such as Science, Geography, Language and Economics in the Arab world reached Europe and influenced the "Early Modern" period of European history. In this time, the Renaissance occurred and Latin and Greek texts (translated in part, by Arab scholars) influenced the intellectual life of Europe and a great importance was placed on the seeking of knowledge. This was also the period when the Europeans colonised and settled in the Americas.

The age of Enlightenment took place in the 18th Century, where, following the weakening of the Catholic Church and the increase in exploration and trade with the Old World nations, Capitalism slowly begun to replace feudalism as the main form of economic organisation. Also, modern Science was starting to be developed and its findings were applied to technological advancements.

The industrial revolution occurred in the 19th Century, where changes in agriculture, transport and manufacturing caused a shift from an economy based primarily on manual labour to one based on industry. Political revolutions occurred across Europe and America during this time, leading to the abolition of feudalism and the formation of nation-states, using Capitalist values to draw their respective constitutions and with the monarchies being retained only for ceremonial purposes.

The 20th Century is considered by many historians, to be the most bloody in history, due to both World Wars and the Cold War, between the Soviet Union and the US. This was also the time when the USA and the European nations drew peace treaties and began to recognise their common goals through their shared values of Capitalism and freedom. They formed the European Union and the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) in order to facilitate this cooperation.

Understanding Science

Science is a fast moving discipline, its definitions continue to change and many advancements have had a huge impact upon human development. In the Medieval period, theories such as spontaneous generation, were abound to explain the evolution of living things, by stating that life spontaneously emerged from inanimate matter. The practice of medicine in this era was equally haphazard, with the theory of the four humours being used to explain the development of disease.

Between the 17th and 20th Centuries, massive developments were made in scientific thought. In the field of Physics, Isaac Newton established his laws of Motion and Gravity; the Atomic bomb was produced; Einstein, Bohr and Planck contributed to quantum mechanics and Edwin Hubble's discoveries led to the formulation of the Big Bang theory. In the field of Chemistry, Mendeleev added newly discovered elements to the Periodic table and Watson and Crick proposed the double stranded helix structure of DNA.

In the field of Biology, Darwin proposed his infamous theory of Evolution by natural selection. More recent developments in the 20th and 21st Centuries include the Internet, robotics, military development, the Human Genome Project, the exploration of Mars, anti-retroviral drugs and the HPV vaccination.

The reasons behind the huge leaps made in science and technology by the West can be understood when we examine the influence of Capitalism and its impact. The Western nations followed capitalism in its entirety, using it to mould the development of their ideas and to solve the problems they faced. They became successful as they took all their solutions from the same basis. They embraced an ideology as used it to judge all of the problems in society. This avoided the inconsistency and internal conflict seen in countries which try to adopt multiple ideologies.

The adoption of common ideals by the Western nations allowed the basic needs of society to be catered for. This allowed citizens to concentrate on ways to better their standard of living. This drive of profit and general advancement led to many developments. Capitalisms potential to derive a profit has driven and continues to drive the motivation of the Western nations to develop.

More importantly though, governments in the Capitalist nations provide the conditions for progression to take place, by fulfilling the basic necessities of their respective populations. They also provide financial investment and an environment which encourages growth and facilitates the development of technology.

For instance, the UK has established 5 research councils, which in addition to the spending provided directly by the government, coordinate and fund particular areas within medical, biological, natural environment, engineering and physical science.

The oil rich states of Kuwait, Qatar and Saudi Arabia, whose economies are comparable to those of the Western nations, spend only 0.2% of their Gross Domestic Product (GDP), on Science - less than a tenth of the 2.3% developed nation average. The number of scientific researchers in the Organisation of Islamic countries (OIC) is also low, with an average of 500 researchers per million, which is minute, compared to the average of over 5000 per million people, in Finland, Iceland and Japan.

The Muslim world

The Muslim world has made very little contribution to the world of science and technology in the last century. When we look at the reasons behind this under development, it becomes clear the economic and social problems facing these countries have impeded their development alongside factors such as war, famine and poverty have compounded the situation greatly. Countries such as Afghanistan and Somalia have been embroiled in civil wars for many decades and more recently, have been the target of military invasions by the USA.

Many of these nations were under colonial rule at some point, often for hundreds of years. For example, Morocco and Algeria were occupied by France, for 40 and 120 years respectively. After gaining independence from the colonial nations, the Muslim world was left in a debilitating economic situation, with much of their resources usurped and which compelled the rulers of the newly formed republics and kingdoms to take loans from the World Bank.

For the majority of countries, the interest accrued on these loans is still being paid back; many decades after the original loans were paid off. Indonesia for instance, which was colonised by the Netherlands and is a country which is considered to be managing its debt well, by the World Bank, it pays $1.4 billion a year of its original loan repayments and an extra $500 000 a year in interest repayments, money which could be spent on technology which would aid the country.

When the colonialists left the Muslim World, they did not leave the inhabitants of those countries to govern themselves; instead, they installed rulers who would continue to support the financial and political institutions of the West and who would be subservient to Western governments. In Iraq, the British colonialists installed King Faisal I as leader, who supported them in the First World War and organised a revolt against the Uthmani Khilafah. In return for their subservience, the governments of Europe and America provided financial and military support to the rulers in the Muslim countries, often ensuring that brutal regimes remained propped up for many decades. This situation remains until the present day, where the rulers of the Muslim countries do not have the interests of their peoples at heart. Rather, they are only concerned with maintaining power and control over their populations and preserving this power within their families or social circles.

The Golden Age of Islam

If we compare and contrast the status quo of the Muslim countries to the Muslim civilisation in the past, the gulf between the two is vast. During the Golden Period of Islam, the time of the Abbasid Khilafah, from the 8th Century to the 15th Century scientists, geographers, poets, engineers and philosophers amongst others, contributed significantly to their respective fields, by creating new inventions and by preserving and building upon earlier work. Their contributions directly affected every major civilisation to come after them and continue to be invaluable to the present day.

Institutions such as public hospitals, psychiatric hospitals, astronomical observatories and public libraries, were the development of Muslims; they made developments in all of the major fields at the time. The deen of Islam, rather than holding these scientists back, was actually the cause of their advancement. In Medicine, the Persian scientist known as Ibn Sina or Avicenna, wrote the famous book "The Canon of Medicine", which was a standard textbook taught in various universities around the world until the 18th Century, in which he introduced: the contagious nature of infectious disease; the use of quarantine to curb the spread of infection; neuropsychiatric conditions such as epilepsy, stroke and dementia; the symptoms and complications of diabetes and the use of clinical trials in experimental medicine. The progress made in Medicine, was due to the Muslims following the commands of Allah as laid out in the Quran and Sunnah. The Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said, in his famous hadith:

"There is no disease that Allah has created, except that He also has created its treatment." (Sahih Al-Bukhari)

The existence of a cure for every disease encouraged the Muslims to make progress in biomedical research. In Mathematics, Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi developed Algebra and used the knowledge he gained to formulate the rules of inheritance as linear equations, which would allow calculation of inheritance shares. Muslim astronomers also developed Trigonometry to assist with determining the phases of the moon to calculate the start of Ramadhan and Eid. Al Hassar, a mathematician from Al-Maghreb, developed the modern symbolic mathematical notation for fractions, where the numerator and denominator are separated by a horizontal bar. Many others contributed to and developed other areas of Mathematics such as Calculus, Geometry and number theory. In the field of technology, engineers such as Al-Jazari, who invented the crankshaft - an essential component in the steam engine and internal combustion engine - and the Banu Musa brothers, who invented the valve and the gas mask, were well known names during the Medieval period. The mechanical alarm clock and the steam turbine were invented by Taqi al-Din, one of a growing number of Muslim polymaths (people whose knowledge covers many fields). A pioneer of practical chemistry was an 8th Century polymath called Abu Musa Jabir ibn Hayyan; he invented most of the chemical processes , which are still used in laboratories today, for example: pure distillation, filtration, sublimation, liquefaction, crystallisation, purification, oxidisation and evaporation.

The knowledge and number of inventions that originated from the Muslim world during the Golden Age of Islam, was truly staggering and influenced so much of the present day technological advancements. There were a number of factors, which facilitated this period of growth and which, unfortunately, do not exist in the Muslim lands in the current day. The primary reason the Muslims were able to develop, was the existence of a Khilafah, a state which was ruled according to the Quran and Sunnah and under which, both Muslims and non-Muslims had their rights protected. The Khilafah took care of the necessities of its citizens and the Khalifah ensured that nobody was without food, shelter, healthcare and education.

The Hudood or punishments were applied to cases where crimes had been committed and this allowed society to live in peace. The armies of the Khilafah protected the citizens of the Islamic state from invasion by foreign nations and were also involved in bringing new lands to be ruled by Islam, in accordance with the people's wishes. The Baitul Mal or "House of Wealth" (the central treasury), collected the taxes from both Muslim and Non-Muslim citizens and ensured that this money was spent on the provision of public services and institutions, such as hospitals and universities, which is where much of the scientific research and developments occurred. The Jews, who lived in Spain during the Ummayad Khilafah, were also able to flourish, because, as their basic needs had been taken care of and they lived in security, an environment existed where they were able to focus on economic and cultural growth. Islam also drove the Muslims to excel in all of the fields that they participated in. The Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said:

"Verily, Allah has enjoined excellence (ihsan) with regard to everything. So, when you kill, kill in a good way; when you slaughter, slaughter in a good way; so everyone of you should sharpen his knife, and let the slaughtered animal die comfortably." (Sahih Muslim)

Islam commands the Muslims to practise Ihsan (excellence) in everything they do. Allah mentions in the Quran:

إِنَّ اللّهَ يَأْمُرُ بِالْعَدْلِ وَالإِحْسَانِ وَإِيتَاء ذِي الْقُرْبَى
"Verily, Allah enjoins Justice, and Ihsan and giving help to kith and kin" (Surah Al-Nahl: 90)

Islam also encouraged Muslims to seek knowledge, both knowledge of the deen and of worldly disciplines. In fact, the distinction between the two was rarely made, in the sense that all knowledge was Islamic knowledge if sought to gain the pleasure of Allah. Hence, learning about the anatomy of the heart was considered Islamic knowledge, if the purpose behind it was as an act of Ibadah (worship) of Allah. Hence, Islam laid out clear guidelines enabling Muslims to be at the forefront of technological and scientific development, whilst remaining true to their faith.

Conclusion

It should now be clear that the developments made by the Capitalist nations, is solely due to the consistency of following a single ideology, rather than due to Capitalism being the correct ideology. The Muslim world, although possessing the correct creed, which is from the creator of universe, has been absent amongst the Ummah in terms of implementation, this is what made them great in the past. It was Islam, which drove the ummah in the past, and it will be Islam insha'Allah, which will make the ummah great once more.

Trackback(0)
Comments (16)add comment

Senthil said:

99% of inventions made by west has turned/turning this mother earth to hostile environment for human life. Infact it not free thinking/open mindset, its only forced thinking/greedy mindset that can accelerate r&d and result in haphazard inventions/inovations which can totaly trun the life's of people living in complete un-hospitable conditions downside up within 300 years.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
November 15, 2010
Votes: +0

Sammy said:

Advances in Science made in the Muslim World

Hydrochloric, Nitric, Acetic, Citric, Sulfuric acid substances discovered. Ultra important for the development of Chemistry. Many say Chemistry was fathered by the Muslims.

Processes of distillation and crystallization discovered. Discovery of the importance of experimentation.

Chemical created that that can dissolve gold, allowing gold to be extracted.

Early classification of elements.

Discovery of the substance of ethanol, which is alcohol.

The thermometer was first used in physics experimentation.

The flywheel creating kinetic energy was invented, the suction pump invented, the valve and the reciprocating piston engine was formed in the 13th century. This was crucial for the modern day engines.

Segmental gears in an engine were invented.

The concept of the steam turbine advanced. Essential for steam trains, steam boats, and all generators powered by steam turbines.


Advances in medicine made in the Muslim World

· The first hospital in Cairo 872CE

· The first insane care center (mental hospital).

· Identification of smallpox

· Allergies identified

· Developing theconcept of the pharmacy

· Eye disease operations introduced

· Over 200 surgical tools introduced

· The first toothbrush used from a tooth cleaning substance called meswak.

· Plastic surgery introduced in the 10th century by doctor Al-Zahrawi, who alsocreated the marking system before plastic surgery.

· The explanation of sight by scientist Ibn al-Haitham

· The invention ofsoap and many cosmetics for hygiene, as being clean is necessary for Muslims.

· The plasterinvented and was first used in the year 1000CE.

Advances in leisure, automatics and miscellaneous made in the Muslim World

The first programmable humanoid robot was invented to entertain guests; it was a musical robot boat, which banged drums to variable rhythms. In the 13th century.

An automatic machine in which artificial birds made of gold sang and swung side to side on a engineered tree was created in the 9th century for the Caliph.

The game of chess created.

The concept of the camera invented in the 10th century.

Musical theory made.

The drink coffee invented.

The glass mirror created.

The mechanical clock invented.

The glider, and parachute invented, the first man to attempt flight in the 10th century.

Perfection of perfumery, creation of many fragrances.

Advances in education made in the Muslim World

· Algebra created

· First university built

· Number systemmade, which was to be used similarly in the rest of the world until present day.

· Trigonometry created

· Significantadvances in geometry and conics

· The first systemfor blind people to see through touch, 600 years before Braille.

· The scales in music created.

Advances in Exploration made in the Muslim World

Chinese Muslim explorer from the Caliphate crosses half the Atlantic Ocean and possibly even reaches shores of Americas 80 years prior to Christopher Columbus; map is drawn of Americas, dated 1418.

Ibn Battuta, travels 75,000 miles, more than any other explorer before him, he voyages deep into Africa, Europe, Middle East, and Asia (China).


Military advances and contributions from the Muslim World


· Some of the first grenades used, made more effective

· The firstaccounts of cannon usage, arguably a Muslim invention.

· The gun inventedin its primitive form, shooting bullets. It has been generally accepted that firearms were a Muslim invention.

· The torpedo wasinvented by a Syrian inventor in the year 1275.


Some other contributions and advances made in the Muslim World

Windmill invented.

The concept of three day meals created.

The first observatory built.

The first certificates for university created the concept that the baccalaureate system is based on.

The carpet invented.

The first soft drink.

The garden developed and designed.

Large agricultural and water transport advances were made.

The pendulum discovered, used in the first pendulum clock in the 15th century.

The modern cheque was invented.

The street lamp invented.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
October 25, 2010
Votes: -1

Tawhid said:

John michaels: As you are members of the Kuffar, it is understandable that you would be against the Muslims uniting.

But the least you can do is not fabricate statistics or such, which again the western immoral and hypocritical world does not pay much heed to anyway. IMF, WB, and other western institutions are seen manipulating statistics as the filthy hypocritical dunces that they are, to revise economic figures to suit their agenda. Not only did they downgrade GDP figures in PPP terms for many a Muslim country but they did the same for PRChina, seeing how China is supposed to overtake USA (already USA and other filthy westerners are in recession as we speak while China keeps on growing fast).

You claimed that Morocco and Indonesia are performing better in economic terms than other Muslim countries because supposedly they are secular. Your assertion is totally false.

Look at the UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia for instances. UAE is wealthier than any western nation, with its average citizen enjoying a GDP/citizen in excess of US$300,000 (no mistakes there, in excess of US$300,000 per citizen, i.e. 300 times 1,000 US$) and Qatar enjoys over US$600,000 per citizen.

Russia, Norway, East Timor, Indonesia are all rich in oil, as is Canada, USA, Brazil, Venezuela, UK, Australia (uranium and other resources). We can see very well which are rich and which are poor.

The arctic and central asia also hold huge deposits of oil and gas, that does not mean those regions AUTOMATICALLY became wealthy.

USA is multiple times richer than Japan in natural resources, yet in 1997, Japan was far wealthier than USA. Care to explain what is wrong with western societies and their immoral codes of social conducts that all these nonwestern countries like Japan, UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia are able to exceed western societies in various economic indicators?

In fact, with close to 1 billion people in the immoral depraved western world, their top 3 largest cities combined have a smaller economic output than one Japanese city of Tokyo.

If you take away the natural resources of USA, and other western countries which they gained by looting resources of natives, where would they be?

To gain better perspectives on that situation, one can look at Timor-Leste (Christian nation with a lot of oil and gas, but no history of looting others' resources, and consequently dirt poor) or Moldova (dirt poor again).

The sad reality of western immorality has been exposed again.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
September 04, 2009
Votes: -3

gets said:

When I googled the key word khilafah, I expeted to get to some kind of "Islamofacsist" propaganda website... though I don't agree with much of the content published on this website, I have to admit that it is really interesting... ( I don't know much about what is discussed so I cannot congratulate anymore....)
Thank you Zeital for your very interesting posts.
Hope that the Khilafah will be lead by peoples like those managing this website!
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 30, 2009
Votes: -1

Zeital said:

A very thought provoking topic, which raises a great many thoughts on this subject. The following points are just an introduction into an area needed more professional research.

Commencing in Europe many breakthroughs were made during the past 250 years, building on the background of the Renaissance emerging from Italy and into Central Europe. From 1700, this does not preclude other civilisations, (including Islamic civilisation), contributed nothing. Europe and Russia’s main contemporary civilisations were the Chinese, Indo-Islamic, Persian, and Ottomans. China, Japan, India and the Islamic civilisations made contributions, although with increasingly lesser significance.

Centers of Islamic civilization flourished in Al-Andalusia, Egypt, Mesopotamia, Persia, Northern Africa/Sicily, and Central Asia. These regions followed the cycle of rise and decline, only to be replaced by another region where a more vibrant successor state emerged to take leadership. The Ottomans, a state founded by people of Turkic origins from Central Asia’s heartlands, emerged from much earlier Persian influenced Turkish states such as the Seljuks. The Seljuks who entered into Islam, were centered on Persia, and adopted Persian culture (as the Ottomans would later do). The Ottomans and their main contemporaries, which were Savafid and Mughals continued developments in technology, engineering, military applications, and astronomy, although Islamic Civilization never quite reproduced the vibrancy, innovativeness and originality during the period known as the ‘Golden Age’. Islamic civilization suffered a terrible jolt and psychological blow following the Tartar-Mongol invasions, and irreparable loss of learning due to ransacked infrastructure.

Crucially, during the earlier period of Islamic expansion, the main contemporaries were the decaying Byzantine Empire, various Indian kingdoms, nomadic tribes of Central Asia, and China. The Muslim world after 1500 would be facing a rather different challenge in the face of European exploration and a civilization revitalized due to the Renaissance, and reignited in its quest for knowledge. Islamic and Chinese civilizations had been dominant for the greater part over 700 – 1500. However, the initiative of overseas exploration, settlement, and discovery passed over to Europe.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 24, 2009
Votes: -1

Zeital said:

Europeans had been seeking alternative trade routes around the regions dominated by the Muslims, and the Portuguese explorers reached China and Japan. The Jesuits sent missions to China and an exchange of technology and knowledge between the two cultures ensued. China under the Ming and later Qing dynasty, has a massive economy, well developed infrastructure, and was self sufficient. Chinese culture had a vibrant tradition of scientific and technological developments, however the pace of discoveries and scientific advancements was slower during the Ming Dynasty and Qing dynasties. Unlike Europe there was less urgency to develop science in China. Rather Chinese scientific development was reinvigorated by contacts from Jesuit missionaries.

The Dutch would become the pre-eminent European maritime/commercial empire in the Far East, developing an intricate and lucrative trading network. The Dutch would be a portal for both China and Japan to the outside world.

Some prominent missionaries were Ferdinand Verbiest, Nicolas Trigault, and Matteo Ricci. This extract from Histoire de l’expédition Christiene au Royaume de la Chine. Is somewhat revealing of the European mindset and desire to actually learn.

“We [the Jesuit missionaries] have seen [China’s] most noble provinces; we enter every day into conversation with the principle citizens, the magistrates and the men of letters; we speak the native language of the Chinese; we have learned by careful enquiry, their habits, customs, laws and ceremonial and, finally (what is of the greatest importance), day and night we have their books in our hands”.

Whilst Chinese society was remaining stable, but less innovative and inclined to pursuing enquiry, Indian civilization developing along its own lines, the Islamic cultures turning inwards, Europe was the civilization showing more vibrancy and willing to adapt new techniques and encourage innovative ideas. Europe’s political division, and internal competitiveness, external quest for trade actually seemed to propel Europe to be even more innovative, adventurous, and consequently a relentless need to advance. Whilst the Renaissance saw Europe gradually emerging from its Dark Ages, the Reformation would be over Europe soul searching for an identity and defining their identity. Hence there was a revival in Classical Roman and Greek Civilization, (to the exclusion of non-European influences), and the rise of Secular Humanism.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 24, 2009
Votes: +1

Zeital said:

CAUSES OF EUROPE DEVELOPING MODERN SCIENCE

Europe was emerging from the grip of the Catholic Church and some Europeans were very brave to challenge the established dogma, launch ‘free inquiry’, and not be curtailed by ‘religious authorities’. This is in an era when torture was more widely carried out and executions against those deemed heretics or challenging authority. Although it seems in our current era, coercion may become more acceptable again. As the Protestant Reformation took root, and the Counter Reformation tried to resist the changes within Europe, the great scientists and astronomers made their mark. Some of which were Christiaan Huygens, René Descartes, Johannes Kepler, Johannes Hevelius, Cassini, Blaise Pascal, and Galileo Galilei, who further developed the Scientific method and laid the groundwork for the advent of modern scientific and mathematical breakthroughs emerging from 1700 onwards. The invention of the moveable type allowed a massive increase in availability of literature with views on governing, philosophy, Greek ideals, scientific and astronomical theories. It was harder for authorities and religious inquisitions to stamp out ‘academic freedom’ so cherished in highly developed technological societies. Discussion and debates were more difficult for conservative authorities to stamp out. Crucially Europe was developing an ‘open mindset’ with respect to scientific and intellectual pursuits. Europeans, beginning with Portugal, Spain, and later the Netherlands and France were consistent in their explorations and mapping of the globe. Within European society, concepts of individual rights and freedom from serfdom were being developed.

The emergent trading empires and rise of an Atlantic Economy pulled international trade and global economic networks more firmly towards Northern and Western Europe. The balance of power within Europe was also shifting from the Mediterranean (Spain, Portugal, Venice, and Genoa) towards the North West and Russia. The financial centre of Europe was shifting towards Amsterdam, with its modern stock markets. Wealth generation due to international trade provided further impetus to colonisation, overseas settlements, and exploration. In turn the increased wealth and control over access to wealth resulted in more funds for pursuit of scientific inquiry. Whereas Spain and Portugal did not really develop an interest into scientific research, Northern and Central Europe did take up the torchlight of science and learning.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 24, 2009
Votes: +0

Zeital said:

MUSLIM SCIENTISTS

The role of Muslim scientists and engineers, although less prominent in comparison to established and emerging industrialised states, still features even during the 20th and 21st Century. Some Muslims scientists (alongside scientists from other developing countries) worked for various projects in the U.S.A and U.S.S.R. An example is the Space Programmes of both Superpowers. It would require more articles to mention their background and contibution.

Unfortunately the Muslim world itself suffers from a rather rigid closed mindset towards allowing free inquiry and encouraging education alongside scientific development. Partly these are due to historical reason and a traumatic recent past, but also it is brought about by change in attitudes. Europe over three centuries was able to extricate itself from intellectual stagnation, influence of clergy, religious dogma, superstitions, and instead develop an inquisitive mind. Ironically the Muslims (and also other cultures) who in the past gave so much impetus to European development, via transaction through Sicily, Al-Andalusia, and Byzantine Empire, ultimately became more closed in upon itself, less flexible, and eventually abandoned the last vestiges of advancement. The terrible experience of the Crusades in the Levant developed lasting negative effects. Although the region saw massive infusion of ideas into Europe, the Tartar-Mongol invasions, Christian counter-offensive in Portugal, Spain, and Sicily, and continual struggle between Muslims and Crusaders left a terrible psychological scar. In the very long run, although Europe suffered a humiliating defeat after the Crusade, and the Ottomans would put an end to the Byzantine Empire, Europe benefited immeasurably in other spheres. The succeeding Muslim scholars, such as Iman Al-Ghazali did not necessarily aid or encourage the development of the natural sciences, whereas the Europeans were eager to learn from Muslim, and indeed other sources as far a field as China and India, or study knowledge from Ancient Greece in their pursuit of knowledge. Europe already began establishing universities and educational establishments to push the boundaries of knowledge where the current sources ran out of anything more to offer.

Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and China have modernised and developed their own scientific and industrial base. Eastern Europe under the Soviet Union established Science Academies and contributed to scientific advancements and Space Exploration. Cuba, Venezuela, Bolivia, Brazil, and Argentine have varying success in developing their own industries or at lest to become self sufficient. Brazil (once a colony of Portugal, even has a Space Programme) whereas Portugal has achieved little to date. India despite chronic domestic problems and poverty, has made developments in a Space Programme, rocketry, and computing. If the emergent economies can seek to have a programme of development and assimilate technologies from other sources, it should be within reach for the Muslim world to let go of its inhibitive complex, and allow its youth and talent to pursue developments in all fields. It would be an idea to show the heritage of Islamic and pre-Islamic Civilisations and their endeavours in fields such as mathematics and engineering. Perhaps this would make Muslims see their capabilities in a more encouraging way.

"We as Muslims must stand and assume full responsibility for our shortcomings and failures. We have failed to learn the lessons of history. We have failed to develop our tremendous human and material resources. We have scarcely begun to break down the barriers of sectarianism, partisanship, nationalism and ethno-centrism, which divide and weaken us. Addressing these issues is well within our ability. Our failure to do so demonstrates a lack of will, resolve and vision on our part first and foremost and cannot be attributed to the Zionist, America, the U.N or anyone else". Imam Zaid Shakir

"When you blame others, you give up your power to change". Robert Anthony

The Crest of the Peacock by George Gheverghese Joseph

http://www.jantarmantar.org/

http://hittininstitute.com/IslamicHistory.aspx
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 24, 2009
Votes: +4

Adnan Khan said:

I think you still need a state to acheive, drive and organise all the points john has made. Western development didn't happen due to the free market, it happened because it was driven by central government
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 23, 2009
Votes: +1

Abdul-Kareem said:

RE: john michaels

You are makling many sweeping statements which are simply not backed up by any evidence or understanding of Islam.

Long before a child enters school they have been educated at home to be subservient to authority to a degree that is unrecognizable in the West. They have been taught that submission is more important than individual thinking.

Evidence? Throughout the Holy Qur'an human beings are asked to think and reflect. The early generations of Muslims were at the forefront of science and technological development. In terms of legal culture many schools of Islamic legal thought were established and principles that are still used today. Being Muslim simply guides a person to the areas where he/she should think and develop rather than wasting effort on hypothetical philosophical theories.

In terms of trade, Muslim culture overemphasizes tribal relationships and is more than willing to accept corruption and bribery than one finds in the West.

Evidence? Islam came to break nationalism and tribalism and moulded Muslims in to one people whose tribe was secondary to the wider Ummah (nation). Islam categorically forbids bribery and corruption. Corruption exists in Muslim countries today because the rulers are not implementing shariah and following Islam. Bribery and corruption exists in the west on a massive scale its just called by different names. So in the UK their MP's call it expenses and in the US they call it campaign contributions.

This website says that establishing a new caliphate is the answer but that will only replace one dictator for another.

Evidence? If you are objective is actually to put forward some serious questions and arguments on the Khilafah then please base them on actual facts and research rather than sweeping statements. If however the objective is simply to make a series of anti-Islamic statements then further discussion is fruitless.

 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 22, 2009
Votes: -1

john michaels said:

"Its an oversimplification to simply say that if the Muslim countries adopted a new teaching method or trading rules then all would be fine. The problems in education, trade and other areas are symptoms of the problem not the problem itself. In fact if you research more you will find that Muslim countries send thousands of people to study in western universities each year. However, when they return to their countries there is no infrastructure or political will for their skills to be used. The countries are ruled by totalitarian dictatorships who are concerned with securing their cut of oil revenues and filling their Swiss bank accounts. "

I don’t think that new teaching methods or trading rules will correct the problem because the problem goes more towards Muslim culture. Long before a child enters school they have been educated at home to be subservient to authority to a degree that is unrecognizable in the West. They have been taught that submission is more important than individual thinking.

In terms of trade, Muslim culture overemphasizes tribal relationships and is more than willing to accept corruption and bribery than one finds in the West. This is not to say that one can’t find Western examples but to the degree to be found in Muslim countries, hardly.

I couldn’t agree more with the observation that most Muslim countries are ruled by totalitarian dictatorships and that these are not only a source of shame but are a real inhibitor to commercial relationships in the modern world.

But let’s stop and think. What is it in Muslim culture that allows this to happen? One can go well before Osman and see the development of these attitudes and and what is the solution? This website says that establishing a new caliphate is the answer but that will only replace one dictator for another. Forgive the more unenlightened for not being persuaded that somehow God will establish a better government on earth through religious adherence. One only has to look at Iran to see how well that’s working out.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 22, 2009
Votes: +1

john michaels said:

"Its surprising in your 'objective thinking' that you have completely neglected the fact that the Muslim world over the past 300 years has suffered occupation and exploitation by the western colonial powers."

Not really true. How long was the Caliphate, the demise of which is so lamented on this website, under occupation and exploitation? Present day Turkey, which is also under fundamentalist Islamic rage for not following sharia and “true” Muslim practices, is the richest and most prosperous majority Muslim nation that is not dependent upon oil revenues. In fact, there is a direct correlation between how well a majority Muslim nation competes in the world economy and how much they observe Islamic principles. Look at the Muslim world. The greater the effort to implement Sharia and the greater the fundamentalist effort to get back to “true” Islam, the less prosperous the nation in terms of being able to survive in the modern world without oil revenues. Morocco and Indonesia are two Muslim nations doing rather well and both are more secular than those Muslim nations where there is disorder caused by fundamentalist efforts to implement Sharia.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 22, 2009
Votes: +4

Abdul-Kareem said:

RE: john michaels

Its surprising in your 'objective thinking' that you have completely neglected the fact that the Muslim world over the past 300 years has suffered occupation and exploitation by the western colonial powers.

Its an oversimplification to simply say that if the Muslim countries adopted a new teaching method or trading rules then all would be fine. The problems in education, trade and other areas are symptoms of the problem not the problem itself. In fact if you research more you will find that Muslim countries send thousands of people to study in western universities each year. However, when they return to their countries there is no infrastructure or political will for their skills to be used. The countries are ruled by totalitarian dictatorships who are concerned with securing their cut of oil revenues and filling their Swiss bank accounts.

Muslims make a distinction between western culture and western civilisation. Whilst we reject the western values we have no problem with adopting the aspects of science and technology that transcend cultures. In fact it was the west that adopted much science and technology from the Muslim world historically.

Regarding your second point about censorship and that somehow this contributes to Islam being behind other cultures. Islam is not behind any other culture. Islam may not be implemented in the form of a state but it exists within individuals and is the fasting growing religion currently.

This website is not a forum with members who are vetted and make comments. We follow the same method as most major news sites where comments can be made on articles. If the comment is deemed appropriate it is posted. Islamic websites have many enemies who make death threats, insults and all sorts of comments that are far from intellectual debate and argumentation, hence the moderation.

Our position is explained in the following article: Islam's view towards Freedom of Speech http://www.khilafah.com/index....-of-speech
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 22, 2009
Votes: -1

john michaels said:

One other reason that Islamic areas are held back is by a belief that ideas have to be vetted and that viewers should be "spared" from reading something that some purist might find objectionable. Take a look at this website, similar to most, not all, but most Islamic websites, where posts are freeflowing and discussions ensue in a timely fashion where opinions are debated and discussed, with the strongest arguments prevailing. In other words, most websites allow free entry of ideas and opinion without being "reviewed". Yes, sometimes objectionable statements are deleted, but on a rare basis.

Censorship of opinions will continue to be a major reason why Islam lags behind other cultures.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 21, 2009
Votes: +4

john michaels said:

What a strange conclusion and recommendation. The Khilafah? Really?

Most objective thought is that the main reason for lack of Islamic acheivement in the last 300 years is socioeconomic. Muslim educational systems, as an example, poorly prepare most students to compete in a globalized economy. An emphasis on strict discipline, usually thought of as a virtue, keeps students from thinking beyond rote memorization. Look at trade as an example of how Muslim nations have failed to keep up with the rest of the world. With the exception of oil exports, where does the Islamic world compete against more competent nations? Example, Egypt has a population greater than South Korea and Taiwan combined but these two nations export more goods in two days than Egypt does all year. Add in a lack of curiosity about the greater world and an emphasis on rejecting what is "Western" and there is little hope for improvement in the dismal showing of Islamic contributions to the modern world.
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 21, 2009
Votes: +5

Daud Fikre said:

Due to injustice of Kufars, that I can hardly take any more to Islam and the Muslims add the Muslims detachment from the Quran & Sunnah, is a slight hint to y the scope looks like that. I Pray. Now finaly there is a revival across the Ummah and for the re-vival that will lead to KHILAFAH I pray...Ameen
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
May 15, 2009
Votes: -2

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy